Since 1963, over 100 Old Dominion University student athletes have received first team All-American honors. The list is highlighted by two athletes who received the award four straight years. They are Terry Hutchinson (sailing, 1987-90) and Jim Weber (sailing, 1987-90). Eleven others earned All-American honors in three seasons. They are Lou Curra (wrestling, 1968-70); Nancy Lieberman (basketball, 1978-80); Anne Donovan (basketball 1981-83); Christy Morgan (field hockey, 1982-84), Marty Kullman (sailing, 1990-92), and John Torgerson (sailing, 1995, 97-98), Flurry Normann (sailing, 1987-89), Patrick Downey (sailing, 1993-95), Heather Pescatello (sailing, 1998-2000), Adam Burns (sailing, 1999-2001), Anna Tunnicliffe (sailing, 2003-05), and Stephanie Roble (sailing, 2009-11).
Nearly 200 student-athletes have earned Academic All-America honors by GTE/CoSIDA (College Sports Information Directors of America) and by various Coaches Associations. Anne Donovan earned the ultimate honor of being inducted into the Academic All-American Hall of Fame in 1994.
OLD DOMINION ALL AMERICAN LISTING
| Name | Sport | Honor | Year(s) |
| Leo Anthony | Men's Basketball | 3rd Team | 1961 |
| Jim Zadell | Baseball | 2nd Team | 1963 |
| Bob Walton | Baseball | 1st Team | 1963 |
| Fred Kovner | Baseball | 1st Team | 1964-65 |
| Bob Walton | Baseball | 2nd Team | 1964 |
| Randy Leddy | Men's Basketball | HM | 1966 |
| Lou Cappi | Track and Field | 1st Team | 1966 |
| Carl Ragland | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1966 ,69 |
| David Lindjhem | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1967 |
| Bob Prichett | Men's Basketball | HM | 1968 |
| David Todd | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1968 |
| Lou Curra | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1968-70 |
| J.P. Leigh | Men's Golf | 1st Team | 1969 |
| Dick St. Clair | Men's Basketball | HM | 1970 |
| Harry Lozon | Men's Basketball | HM | 1970 |
| Jim Cole | Men's Basketball | HM | 1970 |
| Wayne Bright | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1970 |
| Mary Fleet | Swimming | 1st Team | 1970 |
| Skip Noble | Men's Basketball | HM | 1971 |
| Dave Twardzik | Men's Basketball | 3rd Team | 1971 |
| Dave Twardzik | Men's Basketball | 1st Team | 1972 |
| Joel Copeland | Men's Basketball | 2nd Team | 1973 |
| Joel Copeland | Men's Basketball | 1st Team | 1974 |
| Ray Pond | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1974 |
| Terry Perdew | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1974 |
| Oliver Purnell | Men's Basketball | HM | 1975 |
| Wilson Washington | Men's Basketball | 3rd Team | 1975 |
| Wilson Washington | Men's Basketball | 1st Team | 1976 |
| Wilson Washington | Men's Basketball | HM | 1977 |
| Angela Cotman | Women's Basketball | HM | 1978 |
| Inge Nissen | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 1978-80 |
| Nacey Lieberman | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 1978-80 |
| Mike Valantassis | Men's Soccer | 2nd Team | 1978 |
| Ronnie Valentine | Men's Basketball | HM | 1979-80 |
| Ronnie McAdoo | Men's Basketball | HM | 1980-81 |
| Anne Donovan | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 1980-82 |
| Buddy Lee | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1981 |
| Roger Randall | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1981 |
| Mary beth Holder | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1981 |
| Janet Davis | Women's Basketball | HM | 1981-82 |
| Yogi Hightower | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1981-82 |
| Mark Wasinger | Baseball | 1st Team | 1982 |
| Diane Bracalente | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1982 |
| Mark West | Men's Basketball | HM | 1982-83 |
| Christy Morgan | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1982-84 |
| Terry Bell | Baseball | 1st Team | 1983 |
| Adele Mears | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1983 |
| K.C. Fullmer | Sailing | 1st Team | 1983 |
| Eveline Veraart | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1983-84 |
| Nancy Horvatic | Swimming | 1st Team | 1983-84 |
| Ben Ward | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1984 |
| Willemien Aardenburg | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1984 |
| Medina Dixon | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 1985 |
| Tracy Claxton | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 1985 |
| Kevin Bearse | Baseball | 3rd Team | 1985 |
| Todd Azar | Baseball | 3rd Team | 1985 |
| Dawn Hill | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1985 |
| Cheryl Van Kuran | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1985 |
| Jackie Grady | Field Hockey | HM | 1985 |
| Tim Borer | Men's Soccer | 1st Team | 1985 |
| Mike Sweeney | Men's Soccer | 1st Team | 1985 |
| Kenny Gattison | Men's Basketball | HM | 1985-86 |
| Todd Azar | Baseball | 1st Team | 1986-87 |
| Cathy Large | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1987 |
| Jill Fisher | Field Hockey | HM | 1987 |
| Chris Haywood | Men's Soccer | 3rd Team | 1987 |
| Jim Weber | Sailing | 1st Team | 1987-90 |
| Terry Hutchinson | Sailing | 1st Team | 1987-90 |
| Flurry Normann | Sailing | 1st Team | 1987-99 |
| Adrienne Goodson | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 1988 |
| Frank Smith | Men's Basketball | HM | 1988 |
| Jill Fisher | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1988 |
| Mike Martin | Sailing | 1st Team | 1988 |
| Sean Crowley | Men's Soccer | 1st Team | 1988 |
| Cathy Large | Lacrosse | 2nd Team | 1988 |
| Carolyn Sarr | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1989 |
| Lisa Doran | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 1989 |
| Charlie Ogletree | Sailing | 1st Team | 1989 |
| Pat Evangelista | Baseball | 2nd Team | 1990 |
| George Sells | Baseball | 1st Team | 1990 |
| Kelli James | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1990 ,92 |
| Chris Gatling | Men's Basketball | HM | 1990-91 |
| Pam Neiss | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1990-91 |
| Marty Kullman | Sailing | 1st Team | 1990-92 |
| Jeff Ware | Baseball | 3rd Team | 1991 |
| Jon Hurst | Men's Golf | 1st Team | 1991 |
| Nick Garone | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1991 |
| Pete Horst | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1991 |
| Todd Hudgins | Sailing | 1st Team | 1991 |
| Robin Smith | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1991-92 |
| Maikka Hilbrand | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1991-92 |
| Laura Knorr | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 1991-92 |
| Shawn McDonnell | Baseball | 2nd Team | 1992 |
| Jill Reeve | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 1992 |
| Sue Callahan | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1993 |
| Heidi Thoma | Sailing | 1st Team | 1993 |
| Barb DiArcangelo | Lacrosse | 3rd Team | 1993 |
| Patrick Downey | Sailing | 1st Team | 1993-95 |
| Kevin Gibbs | Baseball | 2nd Team | 1994 |
| Jody Staylor | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1994 |
| Karen Neiss | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 1994 |
| Kim Decker | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 1994 |
| Bill Hardesty | Sailing | 1st Team | 1994 |
| Anne Windover | Lacrosse | 2nd Team | 1994 |
| Ericka Davidheiser | Lacrosse | 1st Team | 1994-95 |
| Petey Sessoms | Men's Basketball | HM | 1995 |
| Kevin Gibbs | Baseball | 3rd Team | 1995 |
| Nick Hall | Wrestling | 1st Team | 1995 |
| Kim Decker | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 1995 |
| Samantha Salvia | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 1995 |
| John Torgerson | Sailing | 1st Team | 1995 ,97-98 |
| Clarisse Machanguana | Women's Basketball | HM | 1996 |
| Ticha Penicheiro | Women's Basketball | HM | 1996 |
| Matt Quatraro | Baseball | 2nd Team | 1996 |
| Danielle Chellew | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1996 |
| Mitchell Rodgers | Sailing | 1st Team | 1996 |
| Evangeline Rodgers | Sailing | 1st Team | 1996 |
| Stephanie Sharlow | Sailing | 1st Team | 1996 |
| Odell Hodge | Men's Basketball | HM | 1996-97 |
| Heather Simon | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 1996-97 |
| Clarisse Machanguana | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 1997 |
| Nyree Roberts | Women's Basketball | HM | 1997 |
| Ticha Penicheiro | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 1997 |
| Mimi Smith | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 1997 |
| Rob Ragsdale | Sailing | 1st Team | 1997 |
| Jennifer Pait | Sailing | 1st Team | 1997-98 |
| Nyree Roberts | Women's Basketball | 2nd Team | 1998 |
| Ticha Penicheiro | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 1998 |
| Mimi Smith | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1998 |
| Kelly Driscoll | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 1998 |
| Jaime Hill | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1998 |
| Mark Zagol | Sailing | 1st Team | 1998-99 |
| Heather Pescatello | Sailing | 1st Team | 1998-00 |
| Mery Andrade | Women's Basketball | HM | 1999 |
| Adrienne Yoder | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 1999 |
| Lora Saunders | Sailing | 1st Team | 1999 |
| Jimmy Tanner | Men's Soccer | 3rd Team | 1999 |
| Marina DiGiacomo | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 1999-00 |
| Adam Burns | Sailing | 1st Team | 1999-01 |
| Lucienne Berthieu | Women's Basketball | 1st Team | 2000 |
| Tim Hummel | Baseball | 1st Team | 2000 |
| Marjolijn van der Sommen | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 2000 |
| Adrienne Yoder | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 2000-01 |
| Lucienne Berthieu | Women's Basketball | HM | 2001 |
| Tiffany Snow | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 2001 |
| Emily Ruiter | Sailing | 1st Team | 2001 |
| Corrie Clement | Sailing | HM | 2001 |
| Attila Vendegh | Men's Soccer | HM | 2001 |
| Sally Barkow | Sailing | 1st Team | 2001-02 |
| Elisabeth Biondi | Sailing | 1st Team | 2001-02 |
| Brad Funk | Sailing | 1st Team | 2001-02 |
| Nataly Cahana | Women's Tennis | 1st Team | 2001-02 |
| Hamchetou Maiga-Ba | Women's Basketball | HM | 2002 |
| Melissa Leonetti | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 2002 |
| Matt Allen | Sailing | 1st Team | 2002 |
| Anna Cobb | Sailing | 1st Team | 2002 |
| Elizabeth Bower | Sailing | 1st Team | 2002 |
| Angie Loy | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 2002-03 |
| Corrie Clement | Sailing | 1st Team | 2002-03 |
| Suzanne Woscyna | Lacrosse | 2nd Team | 2002-04 |
| Melissa Leonetti | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 2003 |
| Debbie Capozzi | Sailing | HM | 2003 |
| Attila Vendegh | Men's Soccer | 3rd Team | 2003 |
| Trevor McEachron | Men's Soccer | 1st Team | 2003 |
| Anna Tunnicliffe | Sailing | 1st Team | 2003-05 |
| Cara Gibbons-Neff | Sailing | 1st Team | 2004 |
| Zoltan Csanadi | Men's Tennis | 1st Team | 2004 |
| Kevon Harris | Men's Soccer | 1st Team | 2004 |
| Dana Sensenig | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 2004 ,06 |
| Izak van der Merwe | Men's Tennis | 1st Team | 2004-05 |
| Shareese Grant | Women's Basketball | HM | 2005 |
| Alex Loughton | Men's Basketball | HM | 2005 |
| Dana Sensenig | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 2005 |
| Janelle Engle | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 2005 |
| Emily Bartlett | Sailing | 1st Team | 2005 |
| Brian Cvilikas | Men's Soccer | 2nd Team | 2005 |
| Caroline Nichols | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 2006 |
| Denise Admiraal | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 2006 |
| Edson Elcock | Men's Soccer | 1st Team | 2006 |
| Anthony Shawler | Baseball | 1st Team | 2007 |
| David Horst | Men's Soccer | 2nd Team | 2007 |
| James Nicholson | Wrestling | 1st Team | 2008 ,11 |
| Ryan Williams | Wrestling | 1st Team | 2009 |
| Jaclyn Finney | Sailing | 1st Team | 2009 |
| Stephanie Roble | Sailing | HM | 2009 |
| Dustin Phillips | Football | 1st Team | 2009 |
| Jonathan Plisco | Football | 1st Team | 2009 ,11-12 |
| Gerald Lee | Men's Basketball | HM | 2010 |
| Chris Brown | Wrestling | 1st Team | 2010 |
| Loran Hatch | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 2010 |
| Michael Komar | Sailing | 1st Team | 2010 |
| Nane Joesph | Men's Soccer | 2nd Team | 2010 |
| Stephanie Roble | Sailing | 1st Team | 2010-11 |
| Frank Hassell | Men's Basketball | HM | 2011 |
| Emma Batten | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 2011 |
| Kati Nearhouse | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 2011 |
| Ronnie Cameron | Football | 1st Team | 2011 |
| Yannick Smith | Men's Soccer | 3rd Team | 2011 |
| Christy Longacre | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 2012 |
| Emily Reich | Sailing | 1st Team | 2012 |
| Taylor Heinicke | Football | 1st Team | 2012 |
| Rick Lovato | Football | 1st Team | 2012 |
| Nick Mayers | Football | 2nd Team | 2012 |
| Jack Lowney | Football | 2nd Team | 2012 |
| Chris Burnette | Football | 3rd Team | 2012 |
| Craig Wilkins | Football | 3rd Team | 2012 |
| Dillon Paiva | Sailing | 1st Team | 2012-13 |
| Sarah Breen | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 2012 ,14 |
| Ben Verlander | Baseball | 3rd Team | 2013 |
| Christy Longacre | Field Hockey | 1st Team | 2013 |
| Chloe Constants | Sailing | 1st Team | 2013 |
| Tim Hopkinson | Men's Soccer | 2nd Team | 2013 |
| Kelsey Smither | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 2013-14 |
| Jack Dechow | Wrestling | 1st Team | 2014 |
| Juilia Wisener | Sailing | HM | 2014 |
| Esteban Forrer | Sailing | 1st Team | 2014-16 |
| Alexander Richardson | Wrestling | 1st Team | 2015 |
| Sarah Breen | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 2015 |
| Chris Mecate | Wrestling | 1st Team | 2015-16 |
| Gabriel Smith | Sailing | 1st Team | 2015-16 |
| Jennie Simms | Women's Basketball | HM | 2017 |
| Zach Rutherford | Baseball | 3rd Team | 2017 |
| Jared Young | Baseball | 3rd Team | 2017 |
| Kevin Beazley | Wrestling | 1st Team | 2017 |
| Gabriel Smith | Sailing | HM | 2017 |
| Carter Little | Sailing | 1st Team | 2018 |
| Jeremy Herrin | Sailing | HM | 2018 |
| B.J. Stith | Men's Basketball | HM | 2019 |
| Larry Early | Wrestling | 1st Team | 2019 |
| Rebecca Birch | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 2019 |
| Marlon de Bruijne | Field Hockey | 2nd Team | 2020-21 |
| Carter Trice | Baseball | 2nd Team | 2021 |
| Kyle Battle | Baseball | 2nd Team | 2021 |
| Matt Coutney | Baseball | 2nd Team | 2022 |
| Andy Garriola | Baseball | 3rd Team | 2022 |
| Jana Melichova | Women's Golf | HM | 2022 |
| Yuliia Starodubtseva | Women's Tennis | 1st Team | 2022 |
| Tatsiana Sasnouskaya | Women's Tennis | 1st Team | 2022 |
| Marlon de Bruijne | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 2022 |
| Delphine Le Jeune | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 2022 |
| Jason Hendersn | Football | 2nd Team | 2022 |
| Ece Turkoglu | Women's Soccer | 3rd Team | 2023 |
| Marlon de Bruijne | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 2023 |
| Frederique Zandbergen | Field Hockey | 3rd Team | 2023 |
| Jason Henderson | Football | 1st Team | 2023 |
MONARCH STUDENT ATHLETES NAMED TO THE COLLEGE SPORTS INFORMATION DIRECTORS ASSOCIATION ACADEMIC ALL AMERICAN SQUADS
| 1. Gray Eubank | M. Basketball | 1974 (1st team) |
| 1975 (1st team) | ||
| 2. Dan McCarthy | Baseball | 1975 (2nd team) |
| 3. Daver Moyer | Basketball | 1976 (HM) |
| 4. Reese Neyland | M. Basketball | 1976 (3rd team) |
| 5. Cris Critelli | W. Basketball | 1980 (2nd team) |
| 6. Anne Donovan | W. Basketball | 1982 (2nd team)# |
| 1983 (1st team)# | ||
| 7. Nancy Amos | W. Swimming | 1983 (1st team) |
| 8. Todd Azar | Baseball | 1986 (1st team) |
| 1987 (1st team) | ||
| 9. Pat Evangelista | Baseball | 1990 (2nd team) |
| 10. Pam Neiss | Field Hockey | 1992 (1st team) |
| 11. Shawn McDonnell | Baseball | 1992 (2nd team) |
| 12. Maaike Hilbrand | Field Hockey | 1993 (2nd team) |
| 13. Kevin Larkin | M. Basketball | 1994 (3rd team) |
| 14. Kevin Gibbs | Baseball | 1994 (2nd team) |
| 1995 (2nd team) | ||
| 15. Samantha Salvia | Field Hockey | 1996 (1st team) |
| 16. Matt Quatraro | Baseball | 1996 (1st team) |
| 17. Spiros Blackburn | M. Soccer | 1999 (2nd team) |
| 18. Jeff Eure | Baseball | 2001 (3rd team) |
| 19. Mily Kannarkat | W.tennis | 2001 (3rd team) |
| 2001 (3rd team) | ||
| 20. Attila Vendegh | M.Soccer | 2002 (1st team) |
| 21. Tara Herrmann | Field Hockey | 2003 (3rd team) |
| 22. James Burok | Baseball | 2005 (2nd team) |
| 23. Janelle Engle | Field Hockey | 2006 (1st team) |
| 24. Mary Cate Gordon | Field Hockey | 2006 (2nd team) |
| 25. Alex Loughton | M.Basketball | 2006 (3rd team) |
| 26. Niko Klosterhalfen | M. Soccer | 2018 (3rd team) |
| 27. Iris Achterhof | W. Soccer | 2018 (2nd team) |
| 28. Matt Coutney | Baseball | 2022 (3rd team) |
#Inducted into the GTE/CoSIDA Hall of Fame on May 17, 1994 in Washington, DC.
COACHES ASSOCIATION NATIONAL ACADEMIC SELECTIONS
| 1. Sean Crowley | M. Soccer | 1988 (1st team) |
| 2. Gwen Davis | Field Hockey | 1994-95 (1st team) |
| 3. Samantha Salvia | Field Hockey | 1994-96 (1st team) |
| 4. Sue Dano | Field Hockey | 1994-95 (1st team) |
| 5. Ericka Davidheiser | Lacrosse | 1994 (1st team) |
| 6. Amy Morrisey | W. Tennis | 1995 (1st team) |
| 7. Jenn Karr | Lacrosse | 1995 (1st team) |
| 8. Kim Decker | Field Hockey | 1996 (1st team) |
| 9. Heather Hess | Field Hockey | 1996-97 (1st team) |
| 10. Casie Rhodes | Field Hockey | 1997-99 (1st team) |
| 11. Jamie Hill | Field Hockey | 1997-99 (1st team) |
| 12. Takiyah Gettys | Lacrosse | 1997-98 (1st team) |
| 13. Alison Brown | Lacrosse | 1997 (1st team) |
| 14. Rosemarie van der Rijt. | Field Hockey | 1998 (1st team) |
| 15. David West | M. Tennis | 1998 (1st team) |
| 16. Carly Brown | Lacrosse | 1998 (1st team) |
| 17. Raquel Araujo | W. Tennis | 1998-99 (1st team) |
| 18. Laura Steadman | Field Hockey | 1998-99 (1st team) |
| 19. Becky Bearor | Field Hockey | 1998 (1st team) |
| 20. Lisette Fortanier | Field Hockey | 1998 (1st team) |
| 21 Kailynne Ross | Lacrosse | 1999 (1st team) |
| 22 Amy Wade | Lacrosse | 1999 (1st team) |
| 23. Iva Beli | W. Tennis | 1999-00 (1st team) |
| 24. Johan Varverud | M. Tennis | 1999 (1st team) |
| 25. Adrienne Yoder | Field Hockey | 1999-2001 (1st team) |
| 26. Mary Beth Freeman | Field Hockey | 1999-2001 (1st team) |
| 27. Ashleigh Miller | Field Hockey | 1999 (1st team) |
| 28. Becky Loy | Field Hockey | 1999-2001 (1st team) |
| 29. Jimmy Tanner | M. Soccer | 1999 (3rd team) |
| 30. Mily Kannarkat | W. Tennis | 2000-01 (1st team) |
| 31. Nicky Koclanes | W. Tennis | 2000 (1st team) |
| 32. Alex Cancado | M. Tennis | 2000 (1st team) |
| 33 Dana Wisnieski | Lacrosse | 2001 (1st team) |
| 34. Patricia Arujo | W. Tennis | 2001 (1st team) |
| 35. Ana Radeljevic | W. Tennis | 2001 (1st team) |
| 36. Julia Sotiriu | W. Tennis | 2001 (1st team) |
| 37. Angie Loy | Field Hockey | 2001-03 (1st team) |
| 38. Tara Hermann | Field Hockey | 2001-02 (1st team) |
| 39. Julie Miracle | Field Hockey | 2000-02 (1st team) |
| 40. Laura Steadman | Field Hockey | 2000-01 (1st team) |
| 41. Brooke Thomas | Lacrosse | 2001-2002 (1st team) |
| 42. Kendra Finger | Lacrosse | 2002 (1st team) |
| 43.Jennifer Heister | Lacrosse | 2002 (1st team) |
| 44. Melanie DeJager | Field Hockey | 2002 (1st team) |
| 45. Lynn Farquahar | Field Hockey | 2002-04 (1st team) |
| 46. Marybeth Freeman | Field Hockey | 2002 (1st team) |
| 47. Melissa Leonetti | Field Hockey | 2001-03 (1st team) |
| 48. Christine Walker | Field Hockey | 2001-03 (1st team) |
| 49. Adrienne Yoder | Field Hockey | 2002 (1st team) |
| 50. Geoff Harris | Men's Golf | 2002-03 (1st team) |
| 51. Chris Piercy | Men's Golf | 2002-03 (1st team) |
| 52. Julia Sotiriu | W. Tennis | 2002-03 (1st team) |
| 53. Nataly Cahana | W. Tennis | 2002-04 (1st team) |
| 54. Niklas Oskarsson | M. Tennis | 2003-05 (1st team) |
| 55. Janelle Engle | Field Hockey | 2002-05 (1st team) |
| 56. Cora Gerardi | Field Hockey | 2002-03 (1st team) |
| 57. Mary Cate Gordon | Field Hockey | 2003-05 (1st team) |
| 58. Becky Loy | Field Hockey | 2003 (1st team) |
| 59. Jenna McLane | Field Hockey | 2002-03 (1st team) |
| 60. Katie Moyer | Field Hockey | 2003 (1st team) |
| 61 Danielle Hensil | Lacrosse | 2003 (1st team) |
| 62 Marlaine Smith | Lacrosse | 2003 (1st team) |
| 63. Suzane Wosczyna | Lacrosse | 2003 (1st team) |
| 64. Dana Sensenig | Field Hockey | 2003 (1st team) |
| 65. Elizabeth Sharp | Field Hockey | 2003 (1st team) |
| 66. Kelly Jeffreys | Lacrosse | 2004 (1st team) |
| 67. Tara Hayes | Lacrosse | 2004 (1st team) |
| 68. Valerie Gooch | Lacrosse | 2004-05(1st team) |
| 69. Amber Bazzare | Lacrosse | 2004 (1st team) |
| 70. Alex Loughton | M. Basketball | 2004-06 (1st team) ADA* |
| 71. Caroline Nichols | Field Hockey | 2004-07 (1st team) |
| 72. Dana Sensenig | Field Hockey | 2004-07 (1st team) |
| 73. Sami McLenegan | Field Hockey | 2004-07 (1st team) |
| 74. Margaret Hayes | Field Hockey | 2005 (1st team) |
| 75. Katie Veneziale | Lacrosse | 2006 (1st team) |
| 76. Ashley Stanwick | Lacrosse | 2006 (1st team) |
| 77. Deztany Jackson | W. Golf | 2006 (1st team) |
| 78. Katie Watson | W. Soccer | 2006 (1st team) |
| 79. Jared Kent | M. Soccer | 2006 ( 2nd team) |
| 80. Katie Venziale | Lacrosse | 2006 (1st team) |
| 81. Ashley Stanwick | Lacrosse | 2006 (1st team) |
| 82. Titia Beek | Field Hockey | 2006-07 (1st team) |
| 83. Alyschia Conn | Field Hockey | 2006-08 (1st team) |
| 84. Anna Kern | Field Hockey | 2006-08 (1st team) |
| 85. Hanna Warren | Field Hockey | 2006 (1st team) |
| 86. Kelly Driscoll | Field Hockey | 2006-08 (1st team) |
| 87. Nico Van Nispen | Field Hockey | 2006 (1st team) |
| 88. Katelyn Smither | Field Hockey | 2006-08 (1st team) |
| 89. Jo Ann van Aswegen | Field Hockey | 2006-07 (1st team) |
| 90. Stan Guerrero | M. Golf | 2007 (1st team) |
| 91. Rashelle Fetty | W. Golf | 2007 (1st team) |
| 92. Samantha Mosko | W. Golf | 2007 (1st team) |
| 93. Courtney Seiders | Field Hockey | 2007 (1st team) |
| 94. Kathleen Shea | Field Hockey | 2008-09 (1st team) |
| 95. Katie Ueberroth | Field Hockey | 2006-08 (1st team) |
| 96. Amanda Bieber | Field Hockey | 2007-10 (1st team) |
| 97. Arianne Evans | Field Hockey | 2007 (1st team) |
| 98. Stephanie Kratzer | Field Hockey | 2007-08, 2010-11(1st team) |
| 99. Samantha Richardson | Field Hockey | 2007-10 (1st team) |
| 100. Bailey Mosier | W. Golf | 2008 (1st team) |
| 101. Jestine Angelini | Field Hockey | 2008 (1st team) |
| 102. Paige Clutter | Field Hockey | 2008-10 (1st team) |
| 103. Louise Gericke | Field Hockey | 2008 (1st team) |
| 104. Loran Hatch | Field Hockey | 2008-10 (1st team) |
| 105. Marla Petriello | Field Hockey | 2008-10 (1st team) |
| 106. Julia Simo | Field Hockey | 2008-09 (1st team) |
| 107. Hanna Warren | Field Hockey | 2008-09 (1st team) |
| 108. James Nicholson | Wrestling | 2009-11 (1st team) |
| 109. Kyle Hutter | Wrestling | 2009, 2011 (1st team) |
| 110. Ryan Williams | Wrestling | 2008-09 (1st team) |
| 111. Julie Hodge | Field Hockey | 2009-12 (1st team) |
| 112. Danielle Clutter | Field Hockey | 2009-13 (1st team) |
| 113. Alyschia Conn | Field Hockey | 2008-10 (1st team) |
| 114. Anna Kern | Field Hockey | 2009-10 (1st team) |
| 115. Kimberley Oakes | Field Hockey | 2009-12 (1st team) |
| 116. Devon Seifert | Field Hockey | 2009-11 (1st team) |
| 117. Kathleen Shea | Field Hockey | 2008-09 (1st team) |
| 118. Maartje van Rijswijk | Field Hockey | 2010-12 (1st team) |
| 119. Benjamin Chomette | M.Tennis | 2011 (1st team) |
| 120. Krzysztof Muzalewski | M. Tennis | 2011 (1st team) |
| 121. Albert Ochagavia | M. Tennis | 2011 (1st team) |
| 122. Joanna Dobrowolska | W. Tennis | 2011 (1st team) |
| 123. Diana Ivanova | W. Tennis | 2011 (1st team) |
| 124. Nika Khmolovska | W. Tennis | 2011 (1st team) |
| 125. Kimberley Bradbury | W. Golf | 2011-13 (1st team) |
| 126. Jordynn Collins | W. Lacrosse | 2011 (1st team) |
| 127. Shelby Davis | W. Lacrosse | 2011 (1st team) |
| 128. Emma Batten | Field Hockey | 2011 (1st team) |
| 129. Rebecca Condie | Field Hockey | 2011 (1st team) |
| 130. Megan Hept | Field Hockey | 2011-12 (1st team) |
| 131. Lydia Velzian | Field Hockey | 2011-12 (1st team) |
| 132. Caitlin Walsh | Field Hockey | 2011-13 (1st team) |
| 133. Emily Reich | Sailing | 2011 (1st team) |
| 134. Jessica Milligan | Sailing | 2011 (HM) |
| 135. Thomas Wilde | M. Golf | 2012 (1st team) |
| 136. Tristan Warner | Wrestling | 2012-13(1st team) |
|
137. Nika Khmolovska |
W. Tennis |
2012 (1st team) |
|
138. Dillon Paiva |
Sailing |
2013 (HM) |
|
139. Shannon Wilkins |
Sailing |
2013 (HM) |
|
140. Rachel Austin |
Sailing |
2013 (HM) |
|
141. Phillipine Cleton |
Field Hockey |
2012 (1st team) |
|
142. Marla Petriello |
Field Hockey |
2013 (1st team) |
|
143. Chris Mecate |
Wrestling |
2012 (1st team) |
|
144. Jacob Henderson |
Wrestling |
2012 (1st team) |
|
145. Megan Byas |
Field Hockey |
2013 (1st team) |
|
146. Emily Harting |
Field Hockey |
2012-13 (1st team) |
|
147. Sarah Kazmierski |
Field Hockey |
2013 (1st team) |
|
148. Kelsey Smither |
Field Hockey |
2012-13 (1st team) |
|
149. Sidni Hoxha |
M. Swimming |
2014 (1st team) |
|
150. Reed Mathews |
M. Swimming |
2014 (HM) |
|
151. Rachel Eckert |
W. Diving |
2014-15 (HM) |
| 152. Ingrid Vojcinakova | W. Tennis | 2015 (HM) |
| 153. Reed Mathews | M. Swimming | 2015 (HM) |
| 154. Edward Hubert | M. Swimming | 2015 (HM) |
| 155. Julia Vido | W. Swimming | 2015 (HM) |
| 156. Caty Johnson | Sailing | 2015 (HM) |
| 157. Andrea Luna | Sailing | 2015 (HM) |
| 158. Grace Mason | Sailing | 2015-16 (HM) |
| 159. Jacob Spracher | Sailing | 2015 (HM) |
| 160. Colin Voigt | Sailing | 2015 (HM) |
| 161. Lee Dumaliang | Sailing | 2016 (HM) |
| 163. Gabriel Smith | Sailing | 2016 (HM) |
| 164. Justin Herrera | M. Tennis | 2017 (HM) |
| 165. Jacob Nicolussi | M. Tennis | 2017-18 (HM) |
| 166. Colleen VandePoel | W. Swimming | 2017 (HM) |
| 167. Carter Little | Sailing | 2017 (HM) |
| 168. Jocelyn Rovniak | Sailing | 2017 (HM) |
| 169. Lee Dumaliang | Sailing | 2017 (HM) |
| 170. Jeremy Herrin | Sailing | 2017 (HM) |
| 171. AJ Jacob | Sailing | 2017 (HM) |
| 172. Brendon Wilkins | Sailing | 2017 (HM) |
| 173. Adam Moundir | M. Tennis | 2018 (HM) |
| 174. Francois Musitelli | M. Tennis | 2018-19 (HM) |
| 175. Vincent Schneider | M. Tennis | 2018 (HM) |
| 176. Michael Weindl | M. Tennis | 2018 (HM) |
| 177. Holly Hutchinson | W. Tennis | 2018 (HM) |
| 178. Natalya Malenko | W. Tennis | 2018 (HM) |
| 179. Louie McClelland | W. Tennis | 2018 (HM) |
| 180. Victoria Olivarez | W. Tennis | 2018 (HM) |
| 181. Natalia Vlasova | W. Tennis | 2018 (HM) |
| 182. Ethan Apisa | M. Swimming | 2018 (HM) |
| 183. Peter Durisin | M. Swimming | 2018 (HM) |
| 184. Kenan Carter | Wrestling | 2018 (HM) |
| 185.. Michael McGee | Wrestling | 2018 (HM) |
| 186. Justin Herrera | M. Tennis | 2019 (HM) |
| 187. Bradley Mittleman | M. Tennis | 2019 (HM) |
| 188. Oliver Tobisch | M. Tennis | 2019 (HM) |
| 189. Gavin Burkhart | Sailing | 2019 (HM) |
| 190. Olivia Windemuller | Sailing | 2019 (HM) |
Entire Field Hockey team: 2006, 2007 (1st), 2008 (2nd), 2009 (1st), 2010
Entire Women's Cross Country Team: 1999
Entire Women's Tennis team: 1999, 2001, 2002 and 2003
Entire Wrestling Team: 2013 (8th), 2014 (2nd)
Entire Swimming and Diving Team: 2016, 2017, 2019
Entire Men's Tennis Team: 2018, 2019
*selected by the National Athletic Directors Association.